The opportunity cost of knowing more
November 17, 2026
By Syn Yun Phee
We decide it's time to get fit, so naturally, the first thing we do is open a browser. Weights or cardio? Which programme, which supplements, which running shoes? A few weeks later, we've got a dozen tabs open, a training plan in a spreadsheet and a cart full of gear. What we haven't done is put those shoes on and step out the door.
And it rarely stops at exercise. It could be the business we're still planning to start, the career change we're always one more course away from making, or the note-taking system we've rebuilt so many times that we've stopped taking notes.
It doesn't feel like being stuck. It feels like being thorough. We don't know enough yet, and surely the more we learn, the better our plan will be. If we've spent any time with critical rationalism, that reasoning seems even harder to argue with, because the philosophy tells us that all knowledge is fallible and can always be improved.
Which leaves us wondering when, if ever, we know enough.
Infinite knowledge, finite lives
Improving our knowledge is how we make progress. That's what makes critical rationalism such an optimistic philosophy, and it's why physicist and philosopher David Deutsch argues that all problems are soluble, as long as solving them doesn't break the laws of physics. If a problem hasn't been solved, it's because we don't yet have the right knowledge, and knowledge can always grow.
When we adopt this worldview in our personal lives, we stop treating perplexing problems as permanent dead ends. If our finances are chaotic, our health has stalled or a creative project is going nowhere, we don't throw our hands up and blame fate. We treat it as a knowledge problem. Our current misconcepts, the fallible mental models we use to interpret the world around us and make decisions, aren't good enough to solve them...yet.
But the same idea that helps us make progress can, ironically, also keep us stuck. Because no misconceptMisconcepts are the explanations we hold about how the world works, synonymous with mental models but named deliberately to acknowledge their fallibility. Unlike a misconception, a misconcept is not necessarily wrong.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→ is ever truly complete, the pursuit of better explanations can quietly turn into a trap, where we keep refining one misconcept long after it stopped making a difference to our lives.
Fallibilism describes the nature of knowledge, reminding us that every explanation contains errors. It means that every misconcept can be improved, not that it should be.
The should comes down to the fact that our life resources, our time, mental and physical resourceThe function of our biological machinery.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→, are finite. So whatever we spend on refining one misconcept, we can't spend on anything else. The next best alternative we give up is its opportunity cost. This is where epistemological infinity meets existential finitude.
The person still perfecting their fitness plan may well be improving their understanding of exercise, but they are also paying a price for it. If they haven't started, it's the hours they could've spent actually training. If they have, it's whatever else those hours could have gone towards that would take them closer to their life goals. There's a particular irony in staying up past midnight watching videos on the best sleep routines for optimal performance.
So fallibilism will always tell us our knowledge can be improved. What it can't tell us is whether improving it is the best use of our finite resources, given the goals we've set for ourselves. That's the question opportunity costThe lifetime value of the next best alternative forgone when expending life resources to improve or implement misconcepts.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→ answers. Past a certain point, trying to improve our misconcepts further costs more than it gives back.
Fit for purpose
That point is where a misconcept becomes fit for purpose, when it is good enough to achieve the outcome we care about. Beyond it, further improvement yields diminishing marginal utilityThe incremental gain in lifetime value per incremental unit of life resource expended.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→ and unacceptably high opportunity cost. Where this point sits depends on our current life resourcesThe finite resources we expend to improve or implement misconcepts.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→, our arbitrary life goalsA conjectured desired state that an individual chooses to pursue.Full definition (opens in a new tab)→ and the other misconcepts we need to improve.
For most people who want to be fit and healthy, a handful of ideas, like eating mostly whole foods, moving regularly, mixing strength work with cardio, and having good sleep hygiene, gets them most of the way there. Whether three sets of ten beats four sets of five might matter to a competitive powerlifter, but for most of us, it's well past the point of diminishing returns.
"Since my world picture approximates reality only crudely, I cannot aspire to optimize anything; at most, I can aim at satisficing. Searching for the best can only dissipate scarce cognitive resources; the best is the enemy of the good." — Herbert Simon
We don't need a flawless map of the entire territory. We need a map accurate enough to get us to our chosen destination, without spending the journey drawing coastlines we'll never visit. This means knowing when a misconcept is good enough starts with being clear on our arbitrary life goals, because without a clear sense of where we're going, every coastline looks worth mapping.
What's fit for purpose doesn't just differ between one person and another because of their goals. It changes over time for the same person too. As our goals and circumstances shift, a misconcept that was once fit for purpose can stop being so. The understanding of training that served us well in our twenties may need rethinking after an injury, during pregnancy, or as we get older and take longer to recover. The misconcept didn't change. Our circumstances did, and with them, what we needed it to do.
Once we recognise a misconcept is fit for purpose, the rational move is to accept its remaining fallibility and turn our finite life resources towards the next bottleneck in our lives (which bottleneck that should be is a question of its own, one we explored in an earlier article). That's the theory, at least. In practice, stopping is hard, because it means facing the uncertainty of whether we've stopped too soon.
Stopping is a conjecture too
For many of us, the urge to keep improving a misconcept comes from a fear that we're falling short. What if there's important information we're missing? What if there's an error in our misconcepts and it turns out to matter?
It's a valid fear. We want to use our resources well, after all.
And there almost certainly is an error we haven't found. Fallibilism guarantees it. But we won't know which errors matter until we act. Until then, what we have is our current best conjecture of what to do to achieve our desired outcomes.
"Since all models are wrong the scientist must be alert to what is importantly wrong. It is inappropriate to be concerned about mice when there are tigers abroad." — George Box
Deciding that a misconcept is fit for purpose is itself a conjecture, our best guess that what we know is enough for what we're trying to do. And like any conjecture, it can only be tested against reality once we act on it. We start training and see how our body responds. If our results start drifting from what we expected, whether that's a nagging pain or a stubborn plateau, that's a sign we need a better explanation. That's the error-correction loop at work. We conjecture, act, see what happens, and correct what we got wrong.
When we're unsure whether more refinement is worth it, one question can help: Would knowing more change what I do next?
If not, the extra knowledge might scratch an itch, but it won't change our outcomes. That's usually a sign that we're better off spending our next hour on something else, whether that's the training itself, an earlier night, or whichever part of life has been quietly paying for all that refinement. And if it turns out we stopped too early, there's no need to worry about it now. Reality will let us know, and we can error-correct then.
Knowing enough
Critical rationalism teaches us that we can always know better, and that's what makes it such a powerful engine for progress. But knowing that every explanation can be improved doesn't oblige us to improve every explanation. What matters is choosing which misconcepts are worth our finite life, and having the discipline to leave a good-enough misconcept alone so we can go and live that life. That's the whole point of making a misconcept fit for purpose.
We will never run out of things to know better. We will run out of time to live with what we know.
If this resonated, get Micro Misconcepts in your inbox every Friday.
Subscribe to Micro Misconcepts →